Show Notes
Every operation says the same thing: “We can’t find people.” Almost nobody asks whether the problem is actually the market. In this episode of Handled It, Joe Perkins, Brent Hillabrand, and Lauren Murphy sit down with Ben Brandon of Accrue Partners to draw the line between a talent shortage and a hiring problem.
The conversation gets specific fast: a seven-figure bad hire made under pressure, what “hire for heart, train for skill” looks like in a real interview, and why culture add beats culture fit. The panel also makes the case nobody wants to hear: in every interview, the candidate is interviewing you too.
In this episode, you will learn:
- Why “we can’t find people” is usually a process and expectations problem
- Where bad hires actually happen — and what they really cost
- How to hire for heart and train for skill
- Why “would I have a beer with them?” builds a team of sameness
- How a defined hiring process keeps you from losing candidates to competing offers
Timestamps
0:00 The Cost of a Bad Hire
0:57 Meet the Experts
1:19 The Worst Interview Questions Ever Asked
3:17 Why Companies Keep Hiring the Wrong People
6:22 The $1 Million Bad Hire
8:11 Does Pressure to Fill Roles Lead to Bad Hires?
11:19 Hire for Heart, Train for Skill
16:03 Culture Fit vs. Culture Add: What's the Difference?
21:21 Is the Labor Market Really Tight?
24:14 How to Retain Employees Like Customers
28:06 Fill It Fast or Fill It Right? Rapid-Fire Hiring Debates
30:58 Stop Blaming the Labor Market: Look in the Mirror
Transcript
“We can’t find people” is a familiar refrain for operations leaders. But before writing off a search as a labor market problem, look at what you’re asking for, how you interview, and how long it takes to make an offer. One company spent more than $1 million on a hire who missed all three of the role’s main objectives.
Ask Questions That Tell You Something About the Job
“What animal would you be?” might break the ice, but it gives a hiring manager little to work with. Start with a behavior that matters in the role. If customer service is a priority, ask candidates to describe a time they took care of a customer in a difficult situation. Their example gives you something concrete to discuss and compare across interviews.
How a Bad Hire Cost More Than $1 Million
A company preparing to roll out new field technology put so much weight on experience in one industry that it took its search outside Charlotte. The hire stayed about two years. Between salary, recruiting fees, relocation, and bonus, the company spent more than $1 million, and the hire fell short of the three objectives the company brought them in to accomplish.
Another example showed a different cost. A technically capable finance hire struggled to lead the team, and several employees left. The interview process had missed a capability the job depended on.
Hire for Heart and Train for Skill
A forklift technician needs mechanical aptitude. With that foundation, the team can teach someone to work on a forklift. The interview is a chance to learn how that person takes responsibility, responds to coaching, and handles a customer who needs help.
Define what those behaviors look like for each role, then build questions around them. A good answer gives you a specific situation, the choice the candidate made, and what happened next.
Look for What a Candidate Adds to the Team
“Would I have a beer with this person?” measures how comfortable the interviewer feels. Over time, relying on that instinct can build a team with similar experiences and blind spots.
Shared values still matter. Ask what perspective, experience, or strength the candidate brings that the team could use. A person can thrive in the same culture and approach the work differently.
Define the Hiring Process Before the First Interview
A narrow checklist can make a talent pool look smaller than it is. If the job calls for experience navigating and reporting in a large enterprise system, a candidate who has used a comparable platform may be able to transfer those skills. Decide which requirements are essential before screening people out.
Agree on who needs to interview candidates, what each round will assess, and when the team can make a decision. An open role puts pressure on the people covering it, and extra rounds give competing employers more time to make an offer. A defined process helps the team move quickly while still doing the interviews that matter.
Retain Employees With the Same Intent as Customers
Hiring becomes a recurring burden when people leave as fast as you bring them in. Give employees a clear picture of the job, invest in their development, and show them what a career with the company can look like.
When someone leaves early, review what happened. Did the interview accurately describe the role? Did the person know they were walking into a rebuild? Look at what the team could change in recruiting, onboarding, or management before opening the same position again.
Remember That Candidates Are Interviewing You Too
Check whether your pay and in-office expectations are competitive, and ask whether hiring managers can explain why someone should choose the role. Candidates are listening to how you describe the work and watching how you handle the process. The hiring manager can make the opportunity tangible by explaining what the person will own and how the team will support them.
Final Takeaway
Before blaming the labor market, walk through your hiring process from the candidate’s side. Get clear about what success in the role looks like, ask for evidence of the behaviors that matter, and decide how you’ll move from first interview to offer.